The trouble with.. ummm... wait a minute..
Alireza has a link to a very interesting sounding book. By Richard W. Bulliet titled The Case for Islamo-Christian Civilization
Due to the kind of Islamophobic monoculture of the books that is now the monopoly called Chindigo, I probably will NEVER find it in the local indigo. Even though Irshad Manji's fecalistic book still adorns their shelves (agenda? oh no.. how could Heather have an agenda?)
Maybe the Toronto Reference Lib will get a copy. Until Heather Ricemann takes that over too (private library? we need market competition in libraries.. bring on the monoculture of ideas) for a very convenient price.
Anyhoo, here are some exerpts:
On "clash of civilizations"
"Civilizations that are destined to clash cannot seek together a common future. Like Mathews´ Islam, Huntington´s Islam is beyond redemption. The strain of Protestant American thought that both men are heir to, pronounces against Islam the same self-righteous and unequivocal sentence of [OE]otherness´ that American Protestants once visited upon Catholics and Jews."
On "what went wrong"
"The idea that people in the Middle East once embraced the goal of becoming like Europe and hoped that by adopting European ideas and institutions they would someday experience all of the liberal values we recognize in the Europe of today is nonsense. It assumes a historical outcome for Europe itself that no one even in Europe could have predicted."
On "why do they hate us"
"Those who advanced the Japanese occupation as a model for postwar Iraq seem to have baseball, Hello Kitty, and Elvis impersonators in the back of their minds rather than headscarves and turbaned mullahs. . . . Like latter day missionaries, we want the Muslims to love us, not just for what we can offer in the way of a technological society but for who we are -for our values. But we refuse to countenance the thought of loving them for their values."
On Islam´s ideological shortcomings
"Jim Jones, David Koresh, and Meir Kahane do not typify Christianity and Judaism in the eyes of the civilized West but those same eyes are prone to see Osama bin Laden and Mullah Muhammad Omar as typifying Islam."
On Middle East studies
"The founders of Middle East studies ignored recommendations that they focus on contemporary Islam and focused instead on Middle Easterners trying to act like westerners. There weren´t a lot of these, just as there hadn´t been a lot of converts, but the conviction was strong that those few would be pioneers in bringing western modernity to the region . . . The people we supported as agents of modernity became tyrants."
In other news, I put another hold on Edward Said's book "Orientalism". they frikkin made me wait for 4 months and then called me up when I was out of town. Now the lady said that there were 4 ppl ahead of me, so I asked here to renew the hold. Lets see how this pans out.
10:30:05 AM
|